79 replies to this topic

[Keil]

Literally every week I'm like:

 

GODDAMNIT, DANDY!

[Swar]

Okay Dandy, you can die now.

[Adam]

I'm almost done with season 1, and I'm finally starting to understand the mystery behind the "Murder House"! At the beginning I had no idea what the hell was going on.

[Cannabis]

I read an article that all the seasons are connected! I knew they would do that and called it happening as soon as the second season aired Ryan Murphy is such a genius. He has struck gold with this. I was afraid he was going to ruin it like he ruined Glee but I am gladly mistaken.

[Keil]

I didn't know all four seasons were connected. I only heard Asylum and Freakshow will connect towards the end because bamf Pepper is both seasons and Lily Rabe is said to be a guest actor as that nun from Briarcliff.

[Swar]

I read an article that all the seasons are connected! I knew they would do that and called it happening as soon as the second season aired Ryan Murphy is such a genius. He has struck gold with this. I was afraid he was going to ruin it like he ruined Glee but I am gladly mistaken.

How are they connected? All I know is that each season they give hints on what the next season will be about.

[Keil]

THE ANXIETY!

 

Today:

Spoiler

 

They showed an imagination montage about killing Ma Petite with formaldehyde in a huge cyclinder. Then she was spared.

 

The preview for next week's episode show Ma Petite still in a cylinder filled with formaldehyde.

 

WHY DO YOU PLAY WITH OUT FEELS.

 

Also Seal dude got impaled. That's something.

[Mishelle]

THE ANXIETY!

Today:

Spoiler

They showed an imagination montage about killing Ma Petite with formaldehyde in a huge cyclinder. Then she was spared.

The preview for next week's episode show Ma Petite still in a cylinder filled with formaldehyde.

WHY DO YOU PLAY WITH OUT FEELS.

Also Seal dude got impaled. That's something.

I stan Ma Petite so that had me on edge the whole episode.

[Keil]

Spoiler

 

MA PETITTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Swar]

MUST... RESIST...

I wanna read those spoilers, but I don't wanna ruin the episode D:

[Swar]

Spoiler

When Dandy pointed the gun at his head, I got so happy, but then he killed his mother and moved on. I fucking hate Dandy.

[Keil]

Spoiler

PEPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPEEEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR. YOU BEAuTIfuL SOUL. YOU dESERVE ThE BEST oUT OF LIfFE. *UGLY SOBBING*

Next episode starts on January 7th. Fuck.

[ilovegnj]

all i remember is that the maid in season 1 LOL

[Swar]

Spoiler

That was so sad :'( I didn't know Pepper suffered that much through life.

[Swar]

Spoiler

 

Mixed feelings for this episode. Wow. I hated it at the beggining, but then I loved it. I almost punched my screen because of fucking Dandy. Stupid motherfucker. But then he died. Perfect. I got bored after this part, though. Anyway, I hope next season is better even without Jessica Lange. I can dream lol

 

[Keil]

Spoiler about possible next season.

Spoiler

I've heard the next season will be a fallout/nuclear themed. There were clues like the top hats on coffee cups representing Operation top hat. Also in the scene when Jimmy was about to finger the tupperware ladies the first time when he was sober, there were posters of mushroom clouds in the background. 

 

Spoiler

 

Mixed feelings for this episode. Wow. I hated it at the beggining, but then I loved it. I almost punched my screen because of fucking Dandy. Stupid motherfucker. But then he died. Perfect. I got bored after this part, though. Anyway, I hope next season is better even without Jessica Lange. I can dream lol

 

 

Spoiler

NO ONE SHALL REPLACE MY QUEEN! Lange is perfection. Lange is life. Lange is afterlife. (I also heard she considered acting in season 5).

 

I liked the finale but not enough to tumblr and see all the fandom screeching about Dandy naked in his death or cursing Ryan Murphy down for killing all the freaks. The one and only loose tie I'm unsatisfied with is whether or not Stanley got shot or died way before the massacre due to being the new meep in a cage and probably getting tetanus.

[Swar]

Spoiler

NO ONE SHALL REPLACE MY QUEEN! Lange is perfection. Lange is life. Lange is afterlife. (I also heard she considered acting in season 5).

 

I liked the finale but not enough to tumblr and see all the fandom screeching about Dandy naked in his death or cursing Ryan Murphy down for killing all the freaks. The one and only loose tie I'm unsatisfied with is whether or not Stanley got shot or died way before the massacre due to being the new meep in a cage and probably getting tetanus.

 

Spoiler

I love Jessica Lange. She's everything. And I hope she decides to stay, it won't be the same without her.

 

I actually liked the fact that they all died. It's American Horror Story. Not a fairy tale.

Yeah, I thought about that too. He probably died before the massacre.

[Hopeless]

@Swarley -

Spoiler

This show definitely converted me into a fan of Jessica Lange (as well as introducing me to a whole slew of actors I'm pretty fond of now).  

I also enjoyed the ending... It's kind of awesome how at the end of every season, it's always a surprise who ends up alive. I definitely wasn't expecting Bette/Dot or Jimmy to make it to the end.

[pancakeface]

Why do we only have one board for this? I'm way behind so I've only watched season 1 but I want to discuss dangit.

[Hopeless]

@argonate - you're on Season 1? Seasons 1 and 2 were my favorites, I'm down to discuss.

[Shannon]

Finally caught up. Can't tell if I liked the ending or not.

[pancakeface]

@Hopeless - you're on Season 1? Seasons 1 and 2 were my favorites, I'm down to discuss.

 

@cohle Idk, where you are but I'm just on Season 1

 

so I can only discuss that

Spoiler

WHAT IS UP WITH MOIRA. Like they imply the ghosts are stuck on whatever they were on before they died, and she's stuck on cleaning the house?  Even if you look at it as her being a temptress because she died seducing men, that's hardly fair, she was raped.

 

Also, why and how is she aging? Nobody else has aged a day.

 

And her "young" self has no mortal wounds, as compared to the other ghosts, even her "old" self shows a dead eye but not the head wound that was her cause of death. 

 

Finally, both her and Constance are heavily implying that once her body is found and brought to light, she can finally move on. But everybody else who has died in the house has remained in the house, even if their corpse is no longer on the premises.

 

[Hopeless]

@Cohle -

Spoiler

Honestly, I was expecting everyone to be dead by the end of it, and was pleasantly surprised at the amount of characters that ended up living this season. What do you have mixed feelings about?

 

@argonate -

Spoiler

Yeah, she's got some weird shit about her - apparently some ghosts can just have special rules, and hers is that the "pure of heart" see her as the old lady that she is (even though you're right, why would there even be an "old" version of her) and men with "impure thoughts" see her in her "young" form. Like, she feels so strongly about this - since she blames her death on men (that they only view her as a sexual object) - that her ghost manipulates it's form to "catch" cheating men, but also to make women feel safer (as well as men who have proved their humanity to her). If feelings could make your ghost do special things, might as well give each ghost some sort of unique ability reflecting their deaths instead of just Moira. 

If I had to make up a reason for her and Constance implying Moira's freedom upon discovery of her body, I'd say they just mean that finding her body would bring Moira closure - maybe the closure Moira would need to reach the other side Otherwise yeah, she's only there because she died in the house, like everyone else. She must clean because it's a decent cover story for being visible and keeping a close eye on people in the house, and I guess it also makes it easier to talk to people like Constance. (yeah ok there might be plot holes for the sake of drama but oh well)   

[pancakeface]

@Hopeless

Spoiler

The inconsistencies make it so difficult to figure out the "rules" per se, but as you said some ghosts seem to have special rules. Like if you noticed, quite a few of them don't have their fatal wounds but for some reason Nora has her head wound. Not to mention the writers really made it convenient for them, Nora was lucid for like a couple of visits after her death but is an amnesiac mess for everything else. She keeps missing her baby but when they show Tate as a child, she's still aware of Thaddeus being in the basement.

 

I don't think Moira would have been able to leave though because the Black Dahlia got her dream of being famous and managed to get closure but that just allowed her to come to peace with being stuck in the house forever. Sorry, I'm a plot hole spotter.

[pancakeface]

Today has been all about shameless gravedigs for me. I just got up to speed with season 2 of AHS so naturally I came to this year old thread to see what others were saying about it

 

@Mishelle

YASSSSSSSSSS! I'm so stoked for the premiere. I'm impressed that the producers decided to use real extraordinary people 

 

Spoiler

 

Spoiler

I was so disappointed that this wasn't the mood throughout the season but just a small fantasy bit

 

Season 1 - Ok

Season 2 - Amazing

Season 3 - Gay

 

 

I have high hopes for this one.

 

I struggled a bit with season 2 actually. There were so many different elements interconnected

Spoiler

and i felt that it was unnecessarily complex...to the point where the falling action was a bit rushed and convenient. That said, I thought the ending was amazing