17 replies to this topic

[DonValentino]

In this next chapter of the Shitty GFX Contest, we will be voting on which image we think is the closest representation of shit.

 

Seeing as this is this contest's first rodeo, I'll be providing a bit of commentary on the submissions.

 

#1

Spoiler

This image is a very well done piece of shit. Effort was put in, but not too much. 7.8/10 on the MS Paint scale.

 

#2

Spoiler

 One can appreciate the subtle touch of shit by having the reflection outside of the box, although that's really all it has going for it. A bit too neat to be shit, 4.8/10.

 

#3

Spoiler

 A lot is going on here! But is it too much? Shit is a subtle art, we don't want to bog it down with overbearing shittiness. Still, the lack of clean outlines on the hands and money is to be commended. 7.6/10

 

#4

Spoiler

 

What we have here is a very classic, early-Shit era piece. Not much effort, which, if you'll recall, from when I never specified, can be a good or bad thing. 5.8/10

 

#5

Spoiler

 Buscar, indeed. A very low attempt at low art. 3.4/10

 

#6

Spoiler

 It might not appear so at first glance, but a lot of effort was put into this piece. And while too much effort can be a bad thing, for instance when it tries too hard to be shit, or during the truly regrettable moments when a shit piece actually becomes pleasing to the eye, this image does a tremendous job of maintaining it's absolute shittiness. The one negative is that this piece was entirely handmade, which on almost all occasions is way too much effort. Even so, hats off.  7.4/10

 

 

Voting ends when I feel like it

[Bee]

These are hilariously shitty. I love #6 though.

[Coops]

#6 is the best. Hands down. Poor Frizzle will never know.

[HiMyNameIsNick]

Ayyylmao
#6 for sure

[Keil]

The only shitty thing I see in this shitty graphics voting thread is the critique paired with each entry, but every entry was actually good in their execution towards the theme/intention.

[DonValentino]

If the only shitty thing you see is the text then the entries didn't do a good job, which is just not true. They're all uniquely shitty, please don't insult the artists.

[blue]

I enjoy #6 no doubt, but I've gotta give my vote to #1 for pulling off a great idea!

[Lollita]

#6 lmao ^^

[Chappy]

How is there no love for #3? Money

[Maha]

I liked #3 and #6 but #6 made me rofl. 

[Fikri]

voted for #2 because it's the prettiest. i'm sorry i can't help myself!!

[Junjie]

Ohh my god, voted for #3 but I really wanted to vote for #6 too.

 

voted for #2 because it's the prettiest. i'm sorry i can't help myself!!

 

Fikri for next ban pls   Nahh jk Ilu bae~

 

Edit: Oh and yes I enjoyed reading the commentary

Edited by DonJunjie, 21 May 2016 - 08:26 PM.

[Kaddict]

@DonValentino, those critiques were on point. hahaha. Made these sgfx's even better.

The Buscar mention made me lose it... haha

[FelisNoctua]

How is there no love for #3? Money

I loved #3. I think there might be an inside joke for #6, and I don't get it, so it's not as funny for me. On shitty merit alone, I vote #3.

[Coops]

I loved #3. I think there might be an inside joke for #6, and I don't get it, so it's not as funny for me. On shitty merit alone, I vote #3.

It's funny because in the Spring Codies thread Frizzle said "I'm friendly as fuck, you cucks." because he was repeatedly nommed for least friendliest poster. Because he had a tendency to be a bit harsh towards some people. Also, his av is him flipping people off. xD

[Junjie]

It might also be the timing as well, because Frizzle also recently got himself banned, apparently for flipping out after getting 2 warns and a suspension. So the idea of him being 'friendly as fuck' might have become even more entertaining with that.

[Kaddict]

It might also be the timing as well, because Frizzle also recently got himself banned, apparently for flipping out after getting 2 warns and a suspension. So the idea of him being 'friendly as fuck' might have become even more entertaining with that.

 

 

 

I also wonder if this happened before or after the incident...

[Junjie]

I also wonder if this happened before or after the incident...

After, according to the people involved in the banning, who apparently were the only ones (or some of very few) who knew what happened. They said it happened in Private on the day of the warns or something. Many people with access to that section missed it however it happened so fast apparently.