49 replies to this topic

[Nymh]

Honestly, I do care about graphic quality and effort. What I care about more is content and the thought behind the sig.

This coming from the woman who voted for "Comic fucking sans."

That being said, I voted for number 5, because it blows my mind. Wow.

Edited by nymh, 27 October 2011 - 06:34 PM.

[onlyme]

Honestly, I do care about graphic quality and effort. What I care about more is content and the thought behind the sig.

same here. if a sig makes me laugh i vote for it. same if a sig makes me aw.

[Sida]

Honestly, I do care about graphic quality and effort. What I care about more is content and the thought behind the sig.

This coming from the woman who voted for "Comic fucking sans."

That being said, I voted for number 5, because it blows my mind. Wow.

same here. if a sig makes me laugh i vote for it. same if a sig makes me aw.

For me I just ask myself "Which one would I like to have as my own sig?". In this case it's number 10. There was a time though when it was all "omfg that looks great but is too easy to do so no vote for you" though.

[luvsmyncis]

i like #7 but the sentence "do you feel in peril" sounds off.. not grammatically correct me thinks.
i still voted for it cause bears r cool.

I also felt the phrase was worded strangely. Maybe the creator didn't get enough sleep. Or doesn't know English. I do like the bear though.

Also:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=REvmhBO99I4

[onlyme]

For me I just ask myself "Which one would I like to have as my own sig?". In this case it's number 10. There was a time though when it was all "omfg that looks great but is too easy to do so no vote for you" though.

i hope you will find one soon then xP

[Rooshy]

10 is so applicable.

[iargue]

I would have voted for #1 but it looks like they've just taken the stock image from the screen dump, them added the text to it and nothing else

PLEASE tell me are you kidding.

Like... Seriously.

I suggest you immediately download a rom of Mario and school yourself and come back here and vote for Number 1 right away. (And the two people that +reped him in agreement)

[Joanna]

PLEASE tell me are you kidding.

Like... Seriously.

I suggest you immediately download a rom of Mario and school yourself and come back here and vote for Number 1 right away. (And the two people that +reped him in agreement)

http://4.bp.blogspot...mario+death.png
^This one I had a much bigger size but I lost the link.

http://cdn.themis-me...iv/62/62591.jpg

All that need to happen to these is crop+text on a black background.


[THIS IS NOT TO SAY that I don't enjoy #1- in fact its quite clever and funny but still what they say is correct.]

Edited by Joanna, 29 October 2011 - 01:03 PM.

[Waser Lave]

Yeah, it looks like pretty much nothing was done to that. I suspect even I could have managed to create that one.

[Rooshy]

Wow, in that case, it's more of a "best idea" of the week.

[California]

Not voting.
People really could have been more creative with this theme.
Especially considering it's Halloween.

[Eliam]

Not voting.
People really could have been more creative with this theme.
Especially considering it's Halloween.

I don't think you can criticize people's creativity if you didn't enter. Just my personal opinion, though.

[California]

I don't think you can criticize people's creativity if you didn't enter. Just my personal opinion, though.

Kind of a hypocritical response. You're allowed to have an opinion and I'm not? K.

[Badger]

Not voting.
People really could have been more creative with this theme.
Especially considering it's Halloween.

Well if you can do better, why not enter?
People tried their best.

[California]

Well if you can do better, why not enter?
People tried their best.

I have entered before. I think I placed in the first contest. But I don't plan on entering anymore because it's obviously not a serious contest anymore.

[Strategist]

Kind of a hypocritical response. You're allowed to have an opinion and I'm not? K.

You're entitled to your opinion whether you enter or not.

[California]

You're entitled to your opinion whether you enter or not.

Why thank you Strat. I'd rep you but according to the forum I've already given out enough love today.

[Strategist]

Why thank you Strat. I'd rep you but according to the forum I've already given out enough love today.

Well we like to encourage critiques etc as long as they don't get too inflammatory etc etc. So as long as people can give constructive criticism, then i'm all for opinions.

Taken from the rules thread:

People who are not taking part in a competition, staff included, are encouraged to vote in any voting thread that they come across.

Whilst you are not forced to comment in voting threads, we wouldn't mind if you let everyone know what your opinions on the entries are, you're very welcome to do just that.

However, simply posting how none of the entries appeal to you, or general negative comments and flaming will not be tolerated and will be deleted and possible warns will be issued. If you're going to comment, please be considerate of the entrants feelings and explain why an entry didn't appeal to you, or did appeal to you. Simply saying "it sucks" and such will not be tolerated and contributes nothing. Constuctive critiscism is key here

[California]

Well we like to encourage critiques etc as long as they don't get too inflammatory etc etc. So as long as people can give constructive criticism, then i'm all for opinions.

Taken from the rules thread:

People who are not taking part in a competition, staff included, are encouraged to vote in any voting thread that they come across.

Whilst you are not forced to comment in voting threads, we wouldn't mind if you let everyone know what your opinions on the entries are, you're very welcome to do just that.

However, simply posting how none of the entries appeal to you, or general negative comments and flaming will not be tolerated and will be deleted and possible warns will be issued. If you're going to comment, please be considerate of the entrants feelings and explain why an entry didn't appeal to you, or did appeal to you. Simply saying "it sucks" and such will not be tolerated and contributes nothing. Constuctive critiscism is key here

Yeah, I've read those before. Thanks.

[Musician]

I'm not voting either, but it isn't because all of the entries are bad.
It's because I'm an extremely indecisive person and I can't make a choice. xD

[Rooshy]

Why thank you Strat. I'd rep you but according to the forum I've already given out enough love today.

I did it for you.

[Rachel4]

Its Time to announce the winners. Please stop voting

[Strategist]

Ill lock the thread That will stop people voting