55 replies to this topic

[likerobots]

it was tight between 5 &6 for me, althought 2 was pretty neat.
Kinda bummed there isn't more animation on the icons x) but they look wonderful nonetheless, great work to everyone who entered :3

[Spirited]

I really liked #5, especially the colours on adv+ and the programmer animation!

But I voted for #6 because looking at #5 for awhile made me tired. I imagined those user bars beneath the avatars and felt that #5 was kind of too flashy.

[fimend]

Number 5's Programmer bar is awesome. I really like the animations. They're subtle enough that they aren't annoying, but they still add a little something to the page.

[Salamanda]

I dislike pixel fonts. womp womp

[Nonexistent]

Number five is so classy and vibrant, but so clean at the same time

[Steve]

I really wish there was a weed friendly bar ;x

[Waser Lave]

I really wish there was a weed friendly bar ;x

Try Amsterdam.

[Steve]

Try Amsterdam.

Oooh that was actually really clever. I laughed.
Unfortunately, being a tourist...

[Elindoril]

hnngg.

It was hard to choose one.

[Ladida]

I'm in love with 5! <3

I'd have had Hell choosing between 2 and 5 if Advanced+ for 2 wasn't that sad grey. I love the rounded edges.

[luvsmyncis]

Jesus. These are all pretty impressive in their own ways. The backgrounds on #1 are really bold and fun. I love the rounded edges on #2, but don't care for the easter colors. #3 is clean and neat.

I really like how #4 is so different, but I cannot vote for it because that would make all Retired members poop brown, and we all know that color will always be held in our hearts for Contributors only.

Then there's #5 which is nice and neat, has a great variety of colors and ANIMATIONS. How I love blinking things.

#6 is really pretty, and a cool style. I feel like the colors for the member, sotw, and banned are all too close, and I don't know how I feel about the N in the left side.

Choices choices choices.

I suppose in the end I have to choose for myself. I am a Retired member and I have to pick what will look best under my unenthusiastic Frusciante face.
I got it narrowed down to these two..

Because all the others used poop brown or orange. BLEHHH!!
And I just don't think rainbow matches my personality. Purple pink shall suffice.

[Waser Lave]

If we end up with two of them quite close in votes I wonder if we should give the creators a chance to refine their work following the feedback given and have a second round of voting between them?

[Noitidart]

The choice for me was between 2/5 and 6. I went with 6 because 5 looks like what we used to have before. Set 6 is really nice and different.
2 and 5 are basically same just diff bgs.

However my favvvvvvvv single of all them is the Programmer tag from set 5. WOW love the animation!!

[Nymh]

2 and 5 are basically same just diff bgs.

Whaaaat? You crazy

I agree with you on the Programmer animation, but I am a little partial to the Moderator one myself ^^

[Noitidart]

Whaaaat? You crazy

I agree with you on the Programmer animation, but I am a little partial to the Moderator one myself ^^

No way look at it doll same font same stroke on the lettering just the bgs. Not counting the animation because not all are animated.

[Bone]

No way look at it doll same font same stroke on the lettering just the bgs. Not counting the animation because not all are animated.

In Entry 2, the corners are beveled, the font is smaller, and the colors are more subdued.

I would have voted for Entry 2, but it seems to between 5/6 and I dislike 6 strongly enough that I voted for 5.

[Neoquest]

#5 was the clear winner for me. My thoughts on the others:

Spoiler

1: A little too blurry.
2: Second favorite, if there were some cool animations (and possibly a bit better color choice.) I would have voted for it. I think that banned member looks the best which isn't really fair.
3: Pretty nice, a little old style for this newly upgraded forum.
4: Advanced and advanced+ are a little plain. Considering those will be seen quite a bit, I think they should have gotten some color.
5: Perfect! Pretty much exactly what I envisioned.
6: A little plain, but also very nice

[Noitidart]

#5 was the clear winner for me. My thoughts on the others:

Spoiler

1: A little too blurry.
2: Second favorite, if there were some cool animations (and possibly a bit better color choice.) I would have voted for it. I think that banned member looks the best which isn't really fair.
3: Pretty nice, a little old style for this newly upgraded forum.
4: Advanced and advanced+ are a little plain. Considering those will be seen quite a bit, I think they should have gotten some color.
5: Perfect! Pretty much exactly what I envisioned.
6: A little plain, but also very nice

Now this is some quality feedback. We should all do something like this.

[Pilot]

Set five is sexy as hell.

Programmer animation = winnar

[baby0firefly]

well i started mine but had a bad day and didn't get to finish, oh well, these are great!

[Random]

Not voting for 5 means you're aesthetically retarded.

Now this is some quality feedback. We should all do something like this.

[Juturna]

2 and 3 are actually really good, but 5 takes the cake.

[Noitidart]

Whats with the eye roll?!?! I'm sure if I did some work I want feedback. It looks like mostly we're talking about only the good one or two. Jerk..

[Required]

I liked entry #6. Looks clear

[Wynd]

#5 got my vote by a landslide! The animations and colors really did my eye some good.
Feedback for the others:

#1 - I thought it was a bit bury, and the font could have been a little better.
#2 - I liked this one, but the color choices could have been done a little better. They seem a bit dull.
#3 - Would have been my second choice. I'd have to say like #2, the color choices could have been better!
#4 - I thought this one was a bit random. I liked it, but the text and the backgrounds were a bit out of place to me.
#6 - I liked this one a lot as well. Should have added some kind of animations, it would have made it better!