101 replies to this topic

[Jhud0ra]

Cake...it's so delicious and moist.

[Equi]

pie for sure!!

 

apple pie and pumpkin pie my favs...

[Badger]

 

Pie is clearly better.

Edited by Trixic, 06 April 2013 - 08:52 PM.

[Equi]

wow i'm almost the exact opposite of that diagram

 

i hate cake frosting cuz it's way too sweet but the middle is usually ok

 

and i looove pie crust..probably even more than the filling, but i like them best eaten together

 

also what does tiramisu count as?? is that in its own category

[mintpro]

 

Pie is clearly better.

This, but I also like the pie crust and sometimes cake frosting is too sweet/sugary for my taste.

[Muffin]

In terms of taste i can't decide between the two, they are both so scrummy!! So i'm going for cake purely based on aesthetics! Although i'm probably slightly biased based on the fact that i bake cake for a living!

 

You can make such wonderful things from cake! This is my most recent creation, i personally love it although there something quite sinister about tucking into a furby!!

Spoiler

 

[

 

Edited by Muffin, 01 May 2013 - 12:56 PM.

[WOWOWO]

i like both

[Turnip]

 

Pie is clearly better.

 

Everything about this image is wrong??? ? The cake part is great and crust is great too omg ;w;

[Bone]

Everything about this image is wrong??? ? The cake part is great and crust is great too omg ;w;

 

 

AGREED. Too much frosting is always a boner-killer. And the beauty of pie is that the filling and crust are a harmonious union.

[luvsmyncis]

AGREED. Too much frosting is always a boner-killer.

 
Unless someone puts frosting on your boner. Eh? EHHH? *elbow*
Man, this thread always makes me want to bake a cake.

[Bone]

 
Unless someone puts frosting on your boner. Eh? EHHH? *elbow*
Man, this thread always makes me want to bake a cake.

 

I'd just think of the inevitable dental work from so much sugar. There isn't a bigger boner-killer than that.

[budsmokah]

is that pie or cake gives me some type of orgasm then yeah! f*ck yea!

Edited by budsmokah, 14 May 2013 - 08:26 AM.

[Bone]

is that pie or cake gives me some type of orgasm then yeah! f*ck yea!

 

[Fang11]

I like pie. I ♥ cake

[Trichomes]

Today I saw this cake decorated like a pie at the grocery store, and I immediately thought of this thread.

 

[Bone]

Today I saw this cake decorated like a pie at the grocery store, and I immediately thought of this thread.

 

 

The thought of biting into a slice of pie only to find that it's cake is apalling.

[tournesols]

Gotta go with pie. I never liked the taste of cake. Pies can be so diverse, so rich, so simple, so yummy.

 

But I love cheesecake above all.

[ampharos]

Definitely pie. The crust is my favorite part! Especially if it's flakey, and golden, and warm...

I could care less about the filling, though, as long as it's somewhat sweet.

[vaxinas]

I like cake but I have fat mentality. ;/

[jonvj]

Why not both? Cheesecake is my go to desert.

[rintastic]

Pie is best desert. The only cake that can even try to compete is dream cake because its like half cake half jello and thats just the bee's knees.

[Karla]

Sorry, but pie takes the cake. *slapped*

 

Plus it's one of the desserts I enjoy warm.

[Grandmaster]

I like pie better. Cake is a bit too creamy sometimes for me.

[cashmereoxford]

Pie, feel way less guilty after eating it- something about the cake batter is just unsettling.

[VaultBoy]

Pie is so compact and crunchy