30 replies to this topic

[willy101]

Discuss
Basically prequels were terrible IMO compared to original and 1 is the worst star wars of all

agree/disagree?

[Drakonid]

3 is the worst. This is not an opinion, it's a fact, it's a crappy movie with 2 hours of Anakin being a bitch, and only 3 minutes of Obi-Wan kicking his ass...

[ShinaDutchAD]

The originals will ALWAYS be better than the horrid prequels.

For me it goes 4>5>6>3>2>1

Only reason 3 ranks so high is when Anakin/Darth Vader freaks out when he finds out that "he killed Padme".

[luvsmyncis]

3 is the worst. This is not an opinion, it's a fact, it's a crappy movie with 2 hours of Anakin being a bitch, and only 3 minutes of Obi-Wan kicking his ass...

And even then I laughed when Obi-Wan started chopping off limbs. It wasn't supposed to be funny, I don't think.

[fallendevilz]

I still enjoy 3, I think Anakin's awesome in it.
And i'm right :|

[luvsmyncis]

I still enjoy 3, I think Anakin's awesome in it.
And i'm right :|

Yeah, he's awesome if a man acting like whiny little bitches is awesome.
The only thing I liked about the newer ones was Christopher Lee's voice. That's it.

[Abradix]

The originals will ALWAYS be better than the horrid prequels.

It goes 4>5>6>3>2>1

[ShadowLink64]

6>4>5>>>3>1>2

The order I prefer them is a little different, but the old ones still win big-time over the new ones.

The second one was just garbage, and the first one defeated it because Qui-Gon Jinn is awesome.

[Frizzle]

6>4>5>3>2>1

Now the big debate is, if you had a friend, who had not watched any stars film before, what order would you make them watch it in?

Prequels to or

[Bone]

5>4>6>>[...]>>2=3 (as in they both suck) >>> 1

Pic very related.

Spoiler

[Cory]

5 > 4 > 6 = 3 > 2 > 1


Yes, 6 and 3 are almost equal. 3 actually pulls away in some aspects and if they were created around the same time I think 3 would win as 6 would then lack the nostalgia.

Also, for anyone unaware. Star wars was originally meant to have 9 episodes. We may still see a 7,8&9 once lucus decides he needs to fuck up the franchise more.

[luvsmyncis]

Also, for anyone unaware. Star wars was originally meant to have 9 episodes. We may still see a 7,8&9 once lucus decides he needs to fuck up the franchise more.

...

[Ali]

5 > 6> 4> 3> 2> 1

6 was my favourite for many many years but I think 5 is edging it these days for me.

[iargue]

I honestly like all of the star wars movie. The 3rd one was the worst of the rest, but wasn't terrible.

It was well done, unlike anything Star Trek has ever produced. The only issue is that we had a supposedly badass guy turn into a whiny little bitch and then go to the dark side. That was just lame. He should have turned for another reason, like she left him or something. Not that was he as stupid and emotional as possible.

I cried a little when mace windu died I loved that guy.

[Nymh]

It was well done, unlike anything Star Trek has ever produced.

For shame! I am not going to get off topic to debate why Star Trek is clearly far superior to Star Wars in many ways, but I am astonished.

Edited by nymh, 03 November 2011 - 12:55 PM.

[iargue]

For shame! I am not going to get off topic to debate why Star Trek is clearly far superior to Star Wars in many ways, but I am astonished.

How can you even pretend that Star Trex is good? I fall asleep just trying to watch it

Tsk tsk

[Hawk]

Return of the Jedi > A New Hope >Empire Strikes Back

I don't know. I haven't watched them all in a long time. Return of the Jedi, though, sticks with me the most. Empire Strikes Back was my favorite as a kid, but I'm not sure anymore. I think I just liked that there was a battle right at the beginning...

Where the fuck are you guys coming up with other Star Wars movies?

[Cory]

How can you even pretend that Star Trex is good? I fall asleep just trying to watch it

Tsk tsk

can we agree that space balls was better than both?


Also, the new star trek was a great action flick. The old ones were boring though.

[fallendevilz]

can we agree that space balls was better than both?


Also, the new star trek was a great action flick. The old ones were boring though.

Agreed, the new Trek was pretty damn good.. Zachary Quinto as Spock is legend.

[iargue]

can we agree that space balls was better than both?


Also, the new star trek was a great action flick. The old ones were boring though.

Fell.

Asleep.

Watching.

It.

[Nymh]

Agreed, the new Trek was pretty damn good.. Zachary Quinto as Spock is legend.

Zachary Quinto as anything is legend. One of my favorite men alive.

Fell.

Asleep.

Watching.

It.

*hangs head in shame*

[onethreezerotwo]

I honestly like all of the star wars movie. The 3rd one was the worst of the rest, but wasn't terrible.

It was well done, unlike anything Star Trek has ever produced. The only issue is that we had a supposedly badass guy turn into a whiny little bitch and then go to the dark side. That was just lame. He should have turned for another reason, like she left him or something. Not that was he as stupid and emotional as possible.

I cried a little when mace windu died I loved that guy.

On the same page with everything except Mace. I can't stand Will Smith.

[fallendevilz]

Zachary Quinto as anything is legend. One of my favorite men alive.



*hangs head in shame*

Agreed.. I think it's the whole Sylar - Heroes has given me a man-crush :\

[Drakonid]

Agreed, the new Trek was pretty damn good.. Zachary Quinto as Spock is legend.

LEAVE
THIS
PLACE
NOW.

[James]

Agreed.. I think it's the whole Sylar - Heroes has given me a man-crush :\

Oh yeah! I miss Heroes. xD I stopped watching it after Claire went to College or something...

For Star Wars, I'm fine with all of the movies. Don't think I've watched each more than twice to have any specific opinion. lol