27 replies to this topic

[Pamplemousse]

Before voting, please be sure that you have read the rules regarding the voting process found HERE

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7. DISQUALIFIED FOR VOTING ON THEIR OWN SIGNATURE. READ THE RULES LIKE I TOLD YOU
8.

Voting Closes: When...tie-breaker happens. xD Vote guys!

Edited by Pamplemousse, 18 March 2012 - 05:55 AM.
Disqualified signature #7

[onlyme]

oh i like number one : D

and nr eight...

[Blissey]

Had to give it to #3.
I laughed.
Probably more than I should've.
Then laughed again at #8.
Damn.

[Nymh]

Haha I actually LOL'ed at #8 - congrats to whoever that is, that's probably only the second time I have LOL'ed at a picture in my life

I love #1, 3 and 4 ... such a tough choice this week! I think I am gonna go with #1 since it is the best done out of my 3 favorites IMO

Ok here is my feedback on all of them:
#1 if it was a little dirtier and grainier I think I would like it better, and if the animation was longer
#2 WTF srsly?
#3 I wish it was formatted better. I really love the idea though and I think it has potential to be a better sig
#4 This would be so awesome if the cropping was better and the lettering that was added was just a touch higher quality
#5 Is it a gelert? It is pretty but I am having a hard time relating it to Neo/Codex
#6 Heh, it's cute
#7 Unless the Angelpuss is sad because the program manager is broken I can't really see how this relates. It's pretty though
#8 again, haha

[Boggart]

I don't need to explain why I voted for what I did 'cause I'm elitist.

[zryii]

I thought #2 was pretty hilarious, but #1 is an easy winner

[Icey Defeat]

Why is #8 so funny?

[Galadriel]

I thought #2 was pretty hilarious

I must be missing something.
(I see the neocodex link)

I voted for #1 because it is awesome. Nice job, mystery maker.

[Strategist]

#7 is disqualified for voting on their own signature. Read the rules as i told you a few times via PM. You'd think it wouldnt be that hard to understand. Also, don't try and beg me to put it back in.

Haha I actually LOL'ed at #8 - congrats to whoever that is, that's probably only the second time I have LOL'ed at a picture in my life

I love #1, 3 and 4 ... such a tough choice this week! I think I am gonna go with #1 since it is the best done out of my 3 favorites IMO

Ok here is my feedback on all of them:
#1 if it was a little dirtier and grainier I think I would like it better, and if the animation was longer
#2 WTF srsly?
#3 I wish it was formatted better. I really love the idea though and I think it has potential to be a better sig
#4 This would be so awesome if the cropping was better and the lettering that was added was just a touch higher quality
#5 Is it a gelert? It is pretty but I am having a hard time relating it to Neo/Codex
#6 Heh, it's cute
#7 Unless the Angelpuss is sad because the program manager is broken I can't really see how this relates. It's pretty though
#8 again, haha

Yeah #5 is a Gelert so i've been told by the author I also went WTF with #2 but then i saw the Neocodex link on the bar up the top and lol'ed.

[IcedEarth]

I was planning to enter but I didn't get my entry in on time I've just been so busy.
My entry is in the spoiler if anyone wants to see it.

Spoiler

Also, I really like number one. Nice job!

[Icey Defeat]

Can someone explain the joke for #8?

[sarah.]

Can someone explain the joke for #8?

I'm assuming it's his usergroup being Administrator. I had to look twice to notice it myself, lol.

I voted for #3, but also liked #1 and #4 as well.

[NapisaurusRex]

I voted for #3!

[likerobots]

oh my god
i get number 8 now
voted XD

[Xiphos]

#2 cuz im a #2 it was smart LOL

[Bone]

I was planning to enter but I didn't get my entry in on time I've just been so busy.
My entry is in the spoiler if anyone wants to see it.

Spoiler

Also, I really like number one. Nice job!

Whoa, that's awesome. I probably would have voted for this one if you had finished it in time.

[Wynd]

I was planning to enter but I didn't get my entry in on time I've just been so busy.
My entry is in the spoiler if anyone wants to see it.

Spoiler

Also, I really like number one. Nice job!

I really like this. If it were entered in time, I would have voted for this.

I voted for #1 for obvious reasons. I think it's well-done. c:

[likerobots]

I was planning to enter but I didn't get my entry in on time I've just been so busy.
My entry is in the spoiler if anyone wants to see it.

Spoiler

Also, I really like number one. Nice job!

argh, how do you get that effect? do you jusst resize each animation layer so that it zooms out? o-o

[IcedEarth]

Whoa, that's awesome. I probably would have voted for this one if you had finished it in time.

I really like this. If it were entered in time, I would have voted for this.

I voted for #1 for obvious reasons. I think it's well-done. c:

Thanks guys!

argh, how do you get that effect? do you jusst resize each animation layer so that it zooms out? o-o

Nah, I set a camera up to zoom out in After Effects.

[Rainie]

I was planning to enter but I didn't get my entry in on time I've just been so busy.
My entry is in the spoiler if anyone wants to see it.

Spoiler

Also, I really like number one. Nice job!

That's awesome O: ~~
I'm sorry you couldn't make it in time :x

&Voted for 1, good luck to all entrants ^^~

Edited by Rainie, 17 March 2012 - 05:54 AM.

[IcedEarth]

That's awesome O: ~~
I'm sorry you couldn't make it in time :x

&Voted for 1, good luck to all entrants ^^~

Me too but thank you!

[likerobots]

Thanks guys!



Nah, I set a camera up to zoom out in After Effects.

after effects
hnnf another program in the adobe suite that's too complicated for me to learn. i can't even handle illustrator.
do you have a portfolio i can stalk cos i really love your art C;

[Awake]

1,3, and 6 are my top three and it's so hard to pick just one D: but here are my reviews

#1
Pros- I honestly like this signature and I find the idea to be simple and easy to understand. I didn't have to sit and stare at my monitor for minutes while trying to figure out what is going on in this signature.
Cons- It's not really a con because I still think this is excellent, but I do believe that the overall effect might benefit from slowing down the animation a tiny bit.

#2
Pros- Ummm... It says Neocodex on it? o-o
Cons- I honestly don't get it T.T and the spacing between Shockwave and neocodex is off...

#3
Pros- Simple idea and easy to understand. The pony...I mean c'mon everyone knows ponies are worse than kryptonite...
Cons- The inner most border line is running through the top line of text. This really throws me off visually, but I know for some people it wouldn't be an issue.

#4
Pros- Once again a very easy to understand due to the text "The great abing drought of 2012" explaining it to us all.
Cons- I don't find this signature very personable. I mean I know there are LOTS of different opinions on what makes a good signature but in my honest opinion I wouldn't use this and could honestly see it posted in an error report and you had to crop it half way through posting because you forgot that you were looking at nudes when you took the screen shot.

#5
Pros- Pretty artwork The part of the story on the side looks pretty awesome
Cons- Besides the word Desolation I'm not quite sure how this goes with the theme, but it is very pretty ^^

#6
Pros- Explosions! I think the explosion really makes this since you expect something that just exploded to be messy right? o-o
Cons- Visually confusing but in a not too bad way

#8
Pros- I'm confused
Cons- Still pretty confused x-x someone pls explain? (Perhaps my confusion is caused by the fact that I'm so new to the community?)

In the end I voted for #1 as I believe it is my favorite out of my favorites?
Also as a side note please don't get upset about my opinions in my reviews because they are just my opinions and not everyone is going to agree or disagree with what I have to say. Overall I hope I didn't hurt someones feelings by what I had to say.

[Pamplemousse]

Voting is extended until tie-breaker.

[Jun]

Voted for #1, good luck guys (: