I don't agree with that. Firstly you're giving the chickens a human perception on the situation which alone is pointless. Secondly, by imagining yourself in their position you're no longer talking about whether animals should be kept in those conditions, but whether humans should, and applying your conclusion to the chicken scenario. In this case it's ok, but in other cases it can lead you to forget what these things are an alternative to, such as the "natural" method of dying - getting ripped to shreds by another animal and being eaten half-alive with guts hanging out..etc.
I think it's a great idea. Farming is going to happen regardless, and this is just another step to making it more humane.
well since we are talking about the "humane treatment of animals", i think that it is necessary to put yourself in their shoes so that one can sympathize with and understand whether or not treating the animal in a certain way is more acceptable than another.
The animal in question must have some intrinsic worth, while less than a human is still enough for a person to think, "hey i don't think we should be treating them this way because they are suffering." One of the reasons that people think about the suffering of animals is because of the slipper slope thing where they feel that if its okay to do something to an animal then it might become okay to do something like that to a human as well in the future. And of course this train of thought has to begin with the person "imagining themselves in the place of the animal we are talking about.
I mean there are examples of this in this thread, for example
That is probably the scariest real thing I've ever seen. I can totally see humans in those matrices someday for something like fighting wars.
So its not entirely pointless to give the chickens a "human perception" on the situation by asking people to imagine themselves as the chicken. By doing this it helps people to sympathize with them, which is what being humane ultimately means. Otherwise whats the point of being humane to animals right? i could just say something like oh, they are just animals i eat. I don't care how they are treated at all because they are in essence nothing but meat that is going to end up on my plate anyway. I feel nothing for them at all because they have nothing to do with me, are worth nothing to me, and i would never be in a situation like theirs and so I could care less about how they are treated before they end up in my stomach.


Find content
Male



