Quantcast

What works and what is paused ยท Email is limited to account activation and password resets.

Jump to content


systray

Member Since 31 Dec 2010
Offline Mar 22 2011 03:48 PM

#1385429 Do you believe in god?

Posted by systray on 04 January 2011 - 08:46 AM

Right or wrong is not, in this case, a binary choice. It is possible for things to be more right than others. Or, if you prefer, more useful.

The current scientific model is better, it isn't perfect.
Cultural reletavism has nothing to do with it.

To maintain belief in an outdated model, simply because the newer one isn't as good as the one that will come after it, is absurd.


It's very hard to defend a point that I don't personally agree with haha. In this case I have to give in, it is absolutely absurd to not be willing to change your beliefs even though the evidence around you is changing. Grant me this, if some miracle evidence of God and Jesus was to fall from the sky, it would again be possible for that story to be more "right". (I know that's an irrelevant point as far as this discussion goes, just roll with it)

No!
Because that's what the evidence dictates.

Obviously, as time passes, more evidence will accumulate, but that's not the salient point. It is an aside.


I can't agree with you here. The evidence is based on the time period, and the belief is based on the evidence. Therefore, the belief is based on the time period.