19 replies to this topic

[fimend]

Before voting, please be sure that you have read the rules regarding the voting process found HERE

1.

2.

3.

Voting Closes: 12:00 AM NST, Tuesday August 21st

Good luck to the entrants!

[NapisaurusRex]

#2... I don't feel like I should have to explain why. #1 looks like a flag and it would be my second choice.

[Junsu]

#2, then #3.
#1 just seems too simple.. I could make that...

[krakus]

#2. No explanation necessary.

[Kat]

Red green blue..
I swear the Mass Effect 3 nightmare keeps happening.. all the damn time

[onlyme]

I mean... nr. two def is the prettiest. But it's some kind of Manga thing, so I just can't vote for it.
My vote goes to nr. three. It's moving. Moving is good!

[Drakonid]

I mean... nr. two def is the prettiest. But it's some kind of Manga thing, so I just can't vote for it.
My vote goes to nr. three. It's moving. Moving is good!

Had to -rep you...
"some kind of manga thing", I mean wow...

[Liesa]

Had to choose for Link, my brother got me addicted

[GothicxToy]

link is video games guys XD; Legend of Zelda anyone??? XD

I vote for sig two

[esotericaKoalan]

Pity point for number 1.
The person tried at simple typography, which can be really effective sometimes, and he even put effort in font variation.
Unfortunately, it wasn't very effective this time, mainly due to excessive negative space.
(Okay, maybe I'm just justifying why I'm voting for #1 instead of #2...)

Number 2 is just generic c4d spam, and number 3 is just generic animation. And even though I would much rather use number 2 than number 1 in an actual signature, number 1 gets my pity point.

Edited by esotericaKoalan, 20 August 2012 - 07:42 PM.

[Nymh]

Pity point for number 1.
The person tried at simple typography, which can be really effective sometimes, and he even put effort in font variation.
Unfortunately, it wasn't very effective this time, mainly due to excessive negative space.
(Okay, maybe I'm just justifying why I'm voting for #1 instead of #2...)

Number 2 is just generic c4d spam, and number 3 is just generic animation. And even though I would much rather use number 2 than number 1 in an actual signature, number 1 gets my pity point.

Why didn't you enter yours? I like it

[Strategist]

Pity point for number 1.
The person tried at simple typography, which can be really effective sometimes, and he even put effort in font variation.
Unfortunately, it wasn't very effective this time, mainly due to excessive negative space.
(Okay, maybe I'm just justifying why I'm voting for #1 instead of #2...)

Number 2 is just generic c4d spam, and number 3 is just generic animation. And even though I would much rather use number 2 than number 1 in an actual signature, number 1 gets my pity point.

I dont see a vote on #1....

[Turnip]

I mean... nr. two def is the prettiest. But it's some kind of Manga thing, so I just can't vote for it.
My vote goes to nr. three. It's moving. Moving is good!

Heh, Link is from the super popular video game series Legend of Zelda
It has a manga but it's not related to the games (iirc~)!

Besides, this doesn't look very animes/manga to me!

[Bone]

*votes without condescension*

[Dealin]

Im voting for number 3. Honestly, I dont think number 2 follows the rules as posted by the creator of this weeks SoTW:


This post:
http://www.neocodex....1/#entry1616516

AND

For the numerous people who have said this theme is too hard: The reason I want to keep it as only shades of red, green, and blue is because we had a color splash theme and the easiest way to approach this theme would be to slap red, green, and blue onto a black and white picture. I'm not going to be anal about the whole shades of the color thing, but try to remain as true to the theme as possible. It's meant to be a challenge.

It seems like he / she would have greyscaled the image first, then applied the colors. Even then, theres some offshade in it. Its good work, but not in line with this weeks SoTW imo.

Edited by Dealin, 21 August 2012 - 08:40 AM.

[tri]

Since there are 3 entrants will there be a first second or third winner or first second or just first.

Im voting for number 3. Honestly, I dont think number 2 follows the rules as posted by the creator of this weeks SoTW:


This post:
http://www.neocodex....1/#entry1616516



AND


It seems like he / she would have greyscaled the image first, then applied the colors. Even then, theres some offshade in it. Its good work, but not in line with this weeks SoTW imo.

I think what they meant was like a color splash. I would have done a color splash. I personally think Black & White should have been aloud since Black & White since they are really only shades. I entered one but I used black as a shade.

Edited by Dorkie, 21 August 2012 - 08:42 AM.

[Dealin]

Since there are 3 entrants will there be a first second or third winner or first second or just first.



I think what they meant was like a color splash. I would have done a color splash. I personally think Black & White should have been aloud since Black & White since they are really only shades. I entered one but I used black as a shade.

Well i wouldnt consider that fair, since there is a good chunk of "black" in number 2 as a shade.

I would have entered myself, but I didnt think we were allowed to use greyscale, then throw colors on top of it (as the OP said we COULDNT).

[tri]

Well i wouldnt consider that fair, since there is a good chunk of "black" in number 2 as a shade.

I would have entered myself, but I didnt think we were allowed to use greyscale, then throw colors on top of it (as the OP said we COULDNT).

I agree it looks like they used greyscale. But all the parts of the image have some sort of Red, Blue or Green aspect. I do not see any totally black parts.

[fimend]

I would have entered myself, but I didnt think we were allowed to use greyscale, then throw colors on top of it (as the OP said we COULDNT).

What I meant when I said greyscale wasn't allowed was I didn't want all the entries to look like this:

Spoiler

It's not up to the person running the SOTW to dictate how the entries are created. All I care about is what it looks like at the end. #2 is made up of shades of red, green, and blue which was the theme this week, so it's seem to fit the bill in my opinion whether or not they used greyscale to get to the end product.